Q: I mentioned to a friend that I am sending Bert, our new dog who is wild and undisciplined, to a training school to learn to settle down and mind his manners. My friend responded that this trainer uses shock collars to train dogs, which she feels is inhumane. What’s your opinion?
A: The preponderance of research evidence says your friend is correct. For example, a recent study evaluated positive and negative training methods on the short- and long-term welfare of pet dogs.
Reward-based training with treats and play was compared with aversive training, e.g., yelling, jerking the leash, and physically manipulating the dog. The shock collar and other forms of punishment obviously belong in the aversive category….